Skip to main content

Decoding the complexities of Indo-Pak relations

Does India want to dominate Pakistan?

Pakistan’s oldest rival, India, conducts firing on the LoC (Line of Control) over and over, which always ends up suffering persecution and death of our young soldiers. This was not enough, and India began a zero-sum game over Kashmir by taking it under threat and brutally attacking the unarmed Kashmiris. These merciless strikes and direct firings against the country, which earlier remained a part of the subcontinent and where Hindus and Muslims were a union before the British conquest, are somewhat not new but part of Indians and Pakistanis daily lives. These hostilities are the result of untouched wounds originated after the redrawing of boundaries between the two regions—India and Pakistan.

If we go into a little history, it helps in understanding the roots of contentions. In the earlier centuries, when the subcontinent was free from foreign interference, the shape of the social and economic system was different in its own way. There were social and economic fabrics under the subcontinent region that crafted linkages between the diverse cultures. But, after an imperial consolidation, everything faced a sudden change. Although the linkages survived even during the British Raj, they instilled in Muslims that they were a separate nation. This awakened the Muslims, and their quest for national identity started, which brought tremors around the whole region.

Both regions have been bloodthirsty of each other since then, and many times heated arguments have been exchanged between the two, but the flout of ascendancy has never been marked in history. Kashmir has always been the most wanted land stuck between the two nations.

The strokes separation brought to the region still hasn’t been blurred.

In February, the Indian Air Force carried out an aerial strike at Balakot, claimed as non-military in nature, but it was a direct attack on the state’s sovereignty. This move shook the whole region as Pakistan declared it would retaliate.

The current situation between the two states is considered critical because of Kashmir; both are fighting over the third territory, which is the centre of attention and now a battleground for these two states.  The curfew and communications blackout in Kashmir have already entered the fourth week of the month; thousands of Kashmiri citizens continue to be detained by Indian forces, and several have been injured.

India’s inhuman acts in Kashmir, direct firings on the LoC, and so-called surgical strike against its opponent neighbour have left some possible reasons behind to critically analyse the moves in the form no one shed light on.

First could be that India wants to delineate that it is not weak and to establish its hegemony over the South Asian region, which would be so advantageous for a poor country like India, having no proper facilities for its masses. It is to be noted that India is already the strongest power in the South Asian region, thought of as the 6th largest economic power in the global world order.

A second possible reason could be to exhibit that it is ready at every hour to attack its combatant if it doesn’t comply with its demands.

The third point is that Pakistan is already a threat to India and is regarded as an irritant because it is a defiant country in the region that dauntlessly challenges India’s hegemony. To destabilise Pakistan will be economically beneficial for the Indians, as Pakistan’s economy would be crippled, the system would immediately collapse, investors would stop investing, and its defiant nature would automatically phase out. 

India is feeling extremely frustrated over the growing role of Pakistan to facilitate the talks between the US and the Taliban. The US has a lukewarm reaction, but Pakistan is helping it out in this drastic setting, which will improve its relations with the superpower of the globe. 

At this stage, Modi’s party sees itself going underground because of the bold steps it has taken and needs to defend, as Pakistan is not in a state to compromise at any cost.

Last but not least, Pakistan tries to undermine the image of India (diplomatically), which India takes into account as a threat to its national security.

The security dilemma of the state continues because military power always appears offensive to others.

If Pakistan had stopped its wreaking vengeance, then the scuttlebutt about the drastic war would have gridlocked. Pakistan displayed deterrence, but India turned out to be the very first country to negate the very logic of nuclear deterrence.

If you challenge the norm, you are committing suicide; it is quite abnormal.

India seemed like an irrational actor, but it is not. It is very much rational. They constructed the term New-Normal and yearned to make it a norm in the system to often violate the state’s prepotency and open fires on LoC.

Both states will remain on the brink of war until and unless one decides to give up. Pakistan will never let the Indians breach the predominance of the country and take control over the Kashmir’s terrain, so the direct and indirect war will continue for long.

It was the very concept of state supremacy that dictated Pakistan to retaliate because there seemed no other choice, and Pakistan will not compromise on India’s concept of the New-Normal.

I can be reached at "zaroomansoor9@gmail.com"


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

My Shadowed Realm

I used to be the one finding the forever in the temporary things, ignorant of the cruelties, or in other words, the realities of the world. The mansion I created myself years ago was unaware of the pains the world gives at different times; neither was I given one nor ever attempted to go in-depth. Unmindful of the ferociousness, I kept heading forward, never knowing if the world could ever throw me in the place from where I could have nowhere to move toward for refuge, nor any sign to make a journey, or it would standstill my life in the way I had never ever thought of. The fragile mansion couldn’t come to terms with the merciless outside world and got wrapped in the thunderstorm, which retained in the play to enfold everything that came in its way. Time came when life showed its darkest side, directed hurdles in my way to deal with, and kept snatching what meant the most to me. I dealt with the things, endured, and one after another, life catapulted blocks on my tracks. With time, I f...

Book Review - The Kite Runner

A fascinating, emotional, and well-constructed blend of imagination and reality has been delineated by the bestselling Afghan author Khaled Hosseini in his remarkable and most read book, The Kite Runner. The book consists of the overall classification of the Pashtun and Hazara communities, which build up and complete the Afghani society. Further, it depicted the universal tale of friendship amid two kids who were more than brothers—Amir and Hassan—living a profuse lifestyle in the rich district of Kabul and side by side vindication, cataclysm, social and political upheaval, complex and overlapping relationships that entangled them in the intricate connections, and most importantly, an intense hope. The kite festival, which is a tradition of Afghani culture, used to take place each year, and a single victor used to come up from the hundreds and thousands. There were those who were kite runners and others who fought the kites. Hassan and Amir are the main characters of the book; one was ...

When rumors dictate diplomacy, chaos follows

Covid-19—the fatal virus that made history—has also killed off a substantial fraction of the world’s population as the total cases rapidly climbed globally, and the rest are still in a life-threatening situation. Some of the states have managed to control the situation, including China and New Zealand, while on the other side, the death rate of some ill-fated nations like the United States of America, Pakistan, India, etc., is still high, and they are experiencing night terrors on a day-to-day basis. Moreover, even the world’s hegemon lacked good governance and was unable to switch towards maintaining and retaining influence and coping with the challenging conditions. The worst-hit nations somehow survived and, bit by bit, returned to normal life as the daily cases wind down. Furthermore, deeper conspiracy theories have been emerging and doing rounds since the start of this dangerous disease, which contributed to the huge level of deteriorating the crisis even more. These theories are ...